Labor ruling says employees can only have one boss

Dec 15, 2017

The National Labor Relations Board has overturned a 2015 law that made it easier for contractors and workers at franchised businesses to form unions and collectively bargain with big corporations. 

The 2015 NLRB ruling said contract workers at a recycling center were jointly employed by a third party staffing firm and the business they worked for. Sharon Block was a member of President Obama's NLRB. She's now executive director of the labor and worklife program at Harvard Law School. 

“What the Obama board did was try to apply the proper legal standard, but in a way that fit the way that our economy and our business relationships work today,” she said.

The latest ruling found that workers can only be recognized as employees when a firm has what the NLRB calls, direct control, over workers. A contractor doesn’t fit this new test. 

“Nobody likes to have two bosses," said Matt Haller, spokesperson for the International Franchise Association. "Yesterday’s ruling helps clarify where responsibility lies: direct and immediate control." 

Paul Secunda, labor law professor at Marquette University, said this ruling could limit the ability of workers to collectively bargain. 

“Think about trying to organize a McDonald's store," he said. "You’re organizing 10 employees against a local franchisee, as opposed to organizing tens of thousands or hundreds of thousands of employees against the corporate parent in Illinois. There’s a huge difference.” 

The NLRB has a history of shifting decisions according to which party is in control.

Related HR is not there to be your friend. It's there to protect the company Why unions are so worried about right-to-work laws Graduate students win recognition as employees